United States Valuation · Updated Oct 2026
Ferrari 458 Italia Valuation
The current market value of a Ferrari 458 Italia in the United States is US$258,500, based on 7 verified auction sales in the last 12 months. That’s a +22.1% move year-on-year.
Lowest price
US$148,500
Since 2020
Median price
US$296,250
Since 2020 · n=40
Highest price
US$1,430,000
Since 2020
Sold cars
40
All time
Sell-through
100%
Of 40 lots
Marque Index · United States median
US$258,500
+22.1% year-on-year
Sales 12mo
7
Active listings
4
Lowest sale
US$148,500
Highest sale
US$1,430,000
Value YOUR 458 Italia
The headline number is the market median. Yours is different. Add your mileage, transmission, and condition — we’ll cross-reference live listings and recent sales for a honest range tailored to your car.
- Real comparables — every valuation is sourced
- Reasoning paragraph + driver bullets
- No sign-up to see the result
Value by year
Model years with enough verified sales for their own valuation page.
Recent 458 Italia sales
8 most recent · United States
- Source
US$355,000
12k-Mile 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia
9 Oct 2026 · bring-a-trailer · 12,000 mi
- Source
US$153,000
2012 Ferrari 458 Challenge
26 Sept 2026 · bring-a-trailer
- Source
US$533,500
2014 Ferrari 458 Spider
26 Sept 2026 · mecum
- Source
US$341,000
9k-Mile 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia
24 Sept 2026 · bring-a-trailer · 9,000 mi
- Source
US$459,999
7k-Mile 2013 Ferrari 458 Spider
23 Sept 2026 · bring-a-trailer · 7,000 mi
- Source
US$234,117
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia
21 Sept 2026 · bring-a-trailer
- Source
US$500,000
7k-Mile 2013 Ferrari 458 Spider
5 Sept 2026 · bring-a-trailer · 7,000 mi
- Source
US$425,000
7k-Mile 2013 Ferrari 458 Spider
29 Aug 2026 · bring-a-trailer · 7,000 mi
Other Ferrari valuations
Adjacent models and generations in our index.
Track 458 Italia prices over time.
The Marque Monthly. One email, first of the month. Top movers + biggest auction results. Free.
Indicative only — not investment advice. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future value.